The question
Potential ability is a ceiling, not a prediction
A player's potential ability says how good he could become. It does not say how good
he will become, and the gap between the two is the whole of scouting a youngster. Assume every
player 21 and under reaches his potential, and on our careers you would be wrong by about
16 points of current ability on average, and wrong by more than 10 for about two
players in every three. Even among the youngsters who went on to play regularly, more than half
missed it by more than 10.
So the claim we wanted to make was simple and testable: the projected
player is close to the player he actually becomes. Close enough to plan a squad around,
with an honest range around it, and measured on careers the projection was not built from.
Testing that takes two decades per career. To know what a 16-year-old became, you
need him at 16 and again at his peak, years later, in the same save. Each career here was played
through twenty full seasons, then followed player by player from his first season to his last.